Tax update November 2026
The latest tax update and VAT round up for the month.
Tax update provides you with a round-up of the latest tax developments. Covering matters relevant to individuals, trusts, estates and businesses, it keeps you up-to-date with tax issues that may impact you or your business. If you would like to discuss any aspect in more detail, please speak to your usual S&W contact. Alternatively, Liz Hudson can introduce you to relevant specialist tax advisors within our firm.
1. General
1.1 HMRC interest rates to rise
HMRC yearly interest rates on overdue tax will increase by 0.25%, following the Bank of England base rate rise from 3.75% to 4%.
The rate applied to the main taxes will become 8%. The rate of interest on repayments from HMRC will become 3%.
This change generally applies from 24 November but for quarterly interest payments it applies from 16 November and the rates also differ.
2. Private client
2.1 Appeal dismissed on penalties
The FTT found that a taxpayer who claimed not to have understood the questions on the return fully was careless. A “reasonable and prudent” taxpayer would have sought assistance.
The taxpayer, a non-UK resident, let a UK property under the non-resident landlord scheme. Inaccuracies were identified in them, and HMRC issued penalties for carelessness. The taxpayer accepted that he had made errors, but appealed against the penalties on the grounds that he was not careless. Neither he nor a representative for him attended the hearing, but the FTT decided to proceed as adequate notice was given.
Errors made included failing to note on the tax returns that he was not resident, which incorrectly gave him a personal allowance, and on other returns noting that he was non-resident but claiming that he was still entitled to the personal allowance. The FTT found that although English was not his first language, a reasonable and prudent taxpayer would ensure that they understood the wording of the tax return they were completing, or obtain assistance.
The FTT found that his behaviour was careless, and dismissed the appeal.
Al Marri v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1450 (TC)
2.2 Earnings were one taxpayer’s, not the partnership’s
The FTT has found that income earned by a diver could not be treated as that of a partnership with his wife.
A diver submitted a partnership return for him and his wife. Income earned from his diving activities was reported as the income of the partnership, with profits allocated equally between the spouses. HMRC contended that this was personal income, as it came from one company which initially employed him, then contracted with him when he became self-employed. During the period under enquiry he had been employed. The taxpayer did not produce any documents under which this income could have been assigned to the partnership. No partnership agreement was produced, and the company had no agreement with the partnership.
The FTT found that the right to receive income belonged to the taxpayer, not the partnership, so found for HMRC.
Brown & Anor v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1484 (TC)
2.3 CA confirms UT decision on transactions in securities
The CA has upheld a UT decision on a share buyback transaction, finding for the taxpayers that the purpose of the arrangements was not to obtain an income tax advantage.
The taxpayers invested in a company, and the investment qualified for EIS (enterprise investment scheme) relief. The company eventually bought back their shares, primarily to preserve the EIS relief as the taxpayers were concerned about a potential change of government and changes to the EIS rules. HMRC argued that the main purpose was to obtain an income tax advantage, and the FTT agreed. The UT overturned that decision. The transactions did result in an income tax advantage, but this was not the main purpose of the transactions.
At the CA, HMRC argued the main purpose point again, and was again unsuccessful. The CA looked at the history of the TIS legislation, including the outcome of a consultation which it was based on. It agreed with the UT that a main purpose of securing EIS disposal relief is not equivalent to a main purpose of obtaining an income tax advantage under the relevant legislation.
HMRC v Osmond & Anor [2026] EWCA Civ 1440
2.4 Late application for enhanced protection admitted
The FTT has allowed a decade late application for Fixed Protection 2012, finding that having received no information about the lifetime allowance was a reasonable excuse.
The taxpayer, an NHS dentist, retired holding one NHS pension and two personal defined contribution pensions. On turning 75, one provider notified him that a tax liability would be charged as his holdings exceeded the lifetime allowance at the age of 75. This was in 2022, and he then submitted a late application for protection under the 2012 scheme. He argued that this should be accepted, as he had a reasonable excuse. Neither personal pension provider had told him about enhanced protection. Information about it was given to NHS employees retiring from 2006, but he had retired in 2002. Neither of the financial advisers with whom he discussed pensions had raised the issue of enhanced protection.
The FTT found that this amounted to a reasonable excuse and allowed his late application. The lifetime allowance came in four years after he retired, and he had taken reasonable care of his financial arrangements.
Haigh v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1535 (TC)
3. Trusts, estates and IHT
3.1 HMRC letters to trustees
HMRC is sending one-to-many letters to trustees of trusts that it believes may be paying the wrong rate of tax.
The trusts affected are those where tax is paid at the lower rates, but the name of the trust suggests that it could be liable for the higher trust rates. Examples include being named “accumulation trust” or “discretionary trust”. The circumstances of some trusts may have changed since naming, but HMRC is asking trustees and their agents to check if the correct rates of tax are being paid. A response is requested to avoid a compliance check. Recipients can contact HMRC to explain if no corrections are needed, and information is given in the letter on how to make any corrections if needed to past returns.
4. PAYE and employment
4.1 Payrolling of benefits – new exception process for globally mobile employees
HMRC has published a new process allowing employers to apply for an exception from mandatory payrolling of benefits for some globally mobile employees.
From April 2027, employers will generally be required to report company cars and fuel, company vans and fuel and medical insurance benefits through payroll. However, where internationally mobile employees receive benefits across multiple jurisdictions an exception may be available.
Where an exception is granted, employers will be able to continue reporting benefits through forms P11D and P11D(b) instead of through payroll. The exception is for the reporting process only and does not change the amount of tax or NI due.
Employers should apply as soon as they become aware that an employee is, or is likely to become eligible. Exceptions cannot normally be backdated and remain in place until an end date is provided or HMRC is notified that the employee is no longer eligible.
Start or end an exception to mandatory payrolling of benefits - GOV.UK
4.2 Appeal dismissed on taxation of settlement payment
The FTT has found that a settlement payment was made in connection with the termination of employment, so taxable,
The taxpayer received a settlement payment from his former employer after redundancy. He had brought a claim of unfair dismissal, which his employer settled without admitting liability.
He argued that this payment was not in connection with the termination of employment, but was compensation for discrimination. The FTT considered the wording and case law and found for HMRC. The payment was in connection with the termination of his employment, and taxable under s401 ITEPA.
Everson v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 978 (TC)
4.3 Appeal dismissed on participator loan charge
The UT has agreed with the FTT that HMRC was correct to apply a s415 charge when the debtor was substituted in a director’s loan.
The taxpayer was director and sole shareholder of a close company (T). In 2020, a share for share exchange was carried out, through which a holding company (P) was inserted. The taxpayer was a director of P as well. The taxpayer had a director’s loan account with T at the time of the exchange. By the end of the year, the amount was in excess of half a million pounds. The taxpayer at this point entered into an agreement with P and T to novate this, such that the taxpayer owed the sum to P, not T, and P owed T the money as an intra-group loan.
The taxpayer contended that this was not a deemed dividend payment. HMRC argued that a charge arose under s415, as a debt had been written off. The taxpayer argued that the release was for valuable consideration (P taking over the debt), so no charge arose.
The FTT found for HMRC, noting that the purpose of s415 was to tax distributions from close companies made by the release of obligations. A previous case had established that it does not apply if a debt was repaid, but this was not a case where T now had the money, as the debtor had been substituted. The transfer of a bundle of rights and obligations to P was not satisfaction of the debt, so s415 applied and the taxpayer was liable for income tax.
On consideration of case law, the UT dismissed the taxpayer’s appeal. His argument that the loan had never truly been released was not valid.
Powell v HMRC [2026] UKUT 418 (TCC)
4.4 HMRC publishes new guidance on the mandatory payrolling of benefits
The mandatory payrolling of benefits guidance has been updated again, with HMRC publishing a significant expansion of its practical guidance ahead of the new regime taking effect from April 2027. The changes do not alter the underlying policy but provide employers and payroll teams with greater clarity on how the rules will operate in practice.
New guidance covers a wide range of areas, including the remit of medical benefits, employee communications, the annual payrolled benefits statement, multiple employments, mergers and acquisitions, and various additional common payrolling scenarios. HMRC has also added detailed examples covering company cars, vans, medical benefits, salary sacrifice arrangements, the operation of the 50% tax restriction and how penalties and interest will work in practice.
The update also introduces new sections on third-party benefit providers, employers that cease trading and the interaction with termination payments, together with additional detail on Class 1A National Insurance contributions and the extra Full Payment Submission (FPS) data fields that will be required for real-time reporting.
Although the rules themselves remain largely unchanged, the expanded guidance provides a clearer picture of the processes, systems and employee communications that employers will need to have in place before mandatory payrolling begins in April 2027. Employers that have not yet started preparing should review their current benefits reporting processes and consider whether payroll, HR and benefits systems can accommodate the new requirements.
4.5 Appeals allowed in part on write-off of director’s loan
The FTT found that a written-off director’s loan should have been declared on the return, but lowered the penalty as the behaviour was found to be careless rather than deliberate.
The taxpayer was director of a company that went into voluntary liquidation. His director’s loan account (DLA) at that time had an outstanding balance, which the liquidators wrote off in line with a settlement agreement. He did not include this in his tax return, and HMRC subsequently opened an enquiry into it. The director stated that he was unaware that this should have been included in his return. He had thought that a payment made by him under the settlement agreement was a final settlement to HMRC. HMRC explained that this was incorrect. The director later argued that the DLA related to rental payments, not payments to himself, so he had received no benefit but this was simply an error by his former accountants, with whom he had parted ways because of their other errors.
The FTT found that the DLA write-off should have been included on the return, and dismissed that part of his appeal. However, based on his evidence the penalty issued was recalculated as due to careless rather than deliberate behaviour.
Cohen v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1486 (TC)
5. Business tax
5.1 SC treats redress payments as penalties
The SC unanimously held that approximately £28m of consumer redress payments made by the ScottishPower group under settlement agreements with Ofgem were not deductible for corporation tax purposes. Although the payments were not formally penalties, they were agreed under the threat of substantial regulatory fines. They were therefore sufficiently akin to penalties, falling outside the scope of deductible trading expenditure.
Between 2013 and 2016, Scottish Power resolved four OFGEM investigations into serious regulatory infractions by entering into negotiated settlement agreements to avoid substantial financial sanctions threatened by the regulator.
The Court placed significant weight on the fact that the settlements were negotiated under the threat of substantial penalties under the regulatory regime. The Tribunal had found that, without the settlement, penalties of a similar amount would likely have been imposed. As a result, the redress payments were made in place of those penalties and shared their essential character. The Court held that it was wrong to dissect the arrangements and isolate payments that appeared compensatory, such as the £554,013 paid to affected customers. That amount formed part of a wider negotiated package and could not be separated from the settlement as a whole.
The Court confirmed that penalties, and payments made in substitution for penalties, are not incurred wholly and exclusively for the purposes of a trade. Their purpose is to address a regulatory breach and to promote compliance. Allowing tax relief in such circumstances would dilute the intended deterrent effect of the regulatory regime. The decision therefore reinforces that payments arising from regulatory settlements may be non-deductible even where they are described as consumer redress or compensation rather than formal penalties.
Scottish Power (SCPL) Ltd v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKSC 35
5.2 Further developments in foreign dividend litigation
The FTT has released decisions in two cases addressing outstanding issues arising from the long-running litigation concerning the UK taxation of foreign dividends. While neither case establishes a new principle of law, both provide useful guidance on the practical operation of double taxation relief and the interaction of reliefs within the corporation tax framework.
The decision in Prudential and others v HMRC largely represents a continuation of the historic foreign dividend litigation, dealing with a number of remaining computational issues following earlier Court of Appeal decisions. Of particular interest is the Tribunal's consideration of the mechanics surrounding the carry forward of double taxation relief. Although technical in nature, the judgment provides useful clarification on how relief should be calculated and utilised where historic foreign dividend positions are revisited.
In Baillie Gifford China Growth Trust v HMRC, the Tribunal considered the interaction between double taxation relief and brought-forward management expenses. The dispute arose where dividends that had previously been treated as exempt were subsequently treated as taxable, with entitlement to credit for underlying foreign tax. HMRC argued that double taxation relief should be restricted to the element of the dividend remaining after management expenses had been utilised. The Tribunal rejected this approach, concluding that relief was available against the full amount of the dividend.
Post Prudential closure notice applications v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKFTT 1435 (TC)
Baillie Gifford China Growth Trust Plc v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKFTT 1434 (TC)
5.3 New treaty relief process for interest withholding tax errors
HMRC has introduced a formal treaty relief process for businesses that failed to deduct the correct withholding tax from interest paid to overseas lenders. Relief remains available where treaty conditions are met, but businesses will need to pay particular attention to claim deadlines and potential late-payment interest.
For disclosures received on or after 2 November 2026, including those relating to historical failures, the new process replaces HMRC’s previous concessionary treatment. Under that approach, where the overseas lender was entitled to relief under a double tax treaty, HMRC would often agree not to collect withholding tax that the lender could subsequently reclaim and would instead collect only late-payment interest.
Under the new process, UK payers can formally claim treaty relief for UK-source yearly interest paid without the required deduction. The lender must have been entitled to relief under the relevant double tax treaty when the interest was paid, including meeting the relevant requirements on tax residence and beneficial ownership. Where a claim is successful, HMRC can discharge the payer’s unpaid withholding tax liability or repay tax where the payer has already settled that liability.
Claims must be made using HMRC’s prescribed form, with a separate claim and supporting evidence required for each loan and lender. The four-year time limit runs from the end of the UK tax year (5 April) in which the interest was paid, rather than from the end of the company’s accounting period. The claim must also be made separately rather than through the company’s tax return.
Any tax that is not relieved remains payable, and late-payment interest runs from the date the withholding tax should originally have been paid to HMRC until the earlier of payment or submission of a valid claim. Making a disclosure to HMRC does not, by itself, stop interest accruing.
Businesses with earlier disclosures that HMRC has put on hold can use the new process, subject to the relevant time limits, although they should consider the potential late-payment interest implications. Further guidance is still awaited on unresolved cases, particularly where the normal claim deadline has already passed.
Businesses should therefore review cross-border financing arrangements, including group loans, to identify any withholding tax errors and approaching claim deadlines. The process does not authorise future interest payments to be made without deduction. Where treaty relief is available, businesses will still need to obtain the appropriate direction from HMRC before paying interest gross or at a reduced withholding tax rate.
5.4 Quay wall capital allowances case remitted to the FTT
This case concerns whether £57.1m of expenditure incurred on constructing a quay wall at the Liverpool2 container terminal qualified for plant and machinery allowances. HMRC argued that the expenditure related to a dock or harbour structure excluded from relief under the Capital Allowances Act 2001.
The FTT found in favour of the taxpayer. It held that the quay wall was a distinct asset and that, viewed in the context of the taxpayer’s container-handling business, it was more appropriately described as apparatus or plant than as premises. The FTT then held that the expenditure was saved by the machinery exception in List C because it regarded the expenditure as expenditure on installing the ship-to-shore cranes.
The UT allowed HMRC's appeal and remitted the case to a newly constituted FTT for reconsideration. However, it did not reach a final conclusion on whether allowances are available.
The UT found that the FTT had made a number of errors of law, including, analysing the quay wall and cranes as a combined asset rather than considering the quay wall separately, placing excessive reliance on the decision in IRC v Barclay, Curle & Co Ltd and failing adequately to explain key factual findings and why it preferred one its preferred expert evidence over the other. The UT also held that the FTT had applied the wrong test when considering the machinery exception in List C. The FTT treated it as sufficient that the quay wall expenditure was necessary for the cranes to operate. The UT held that the correct test, following Orsted West of Duddon Sands (UK) Ltd v HMRC, is whether the expenditure is sufficiently closely connected with the provision of the machinery, not simply whether it is necessary for its operation.
The decision highlights the UT's strict approach to claims for capital allowances on supporting infrastructure and emphasises that expenditure must have a sufficiently close connection to qualifying plant, rather than merely being necessary for its operation.
The Mersey Docks and Harbour Company Ltd v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKUT 417 (TCC)
6. VAT and indirect taxes
6.1 Home improvement agency services not exempt welfare services for VAT
The Tribunal dismissed Portsmouth City Council's appeals, finding that its Home Improvement Agency (HIA) fees did not qualify for the welfare-services exemption. Although the HIA's work was closely related to residents' welfare needs, the services were not essential to the exempt services as required.
The council’s HIA helped elderly and disabled residents apply for grants and arrange home adaptations, including ramps, stairlifts and accessible bathrooms. Its services included advising applicants, preparing specifications, arranging approvals, coordinating contractors and inspecting completed work. The council sought repayment of VAT charged on its fees, arguing that the services were exempt welfare services.
The Tribunal accepted that the adaptations served a welfare purpose and that the HIA’s services were closely connected to meeting residents’ needs. However, it found that the relevant underlying transactions were the building works supplied by third-party contractors. Those supplies were not exempt, as the contractors were neither public bodies nor charities. The HIA fees therefore failed the Article 134(a) requirement and remained taxable.
Portsmouth City Council v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKFTT 1462 (TC)
6.2 DIY housebuilders scheme and substantial redevelopment
The Tribunal held that a substantial redevelopment of an existing bungalow did not qualify under the DIY Housebuilders' Scheme because the original building had not ceased to exist for VAT purposes. The works were therefore treated as alterations to an existing building rather than the construction of a new dwelling, and the refund claim was denied.
The taxpayers undertook extensive works to a bungalow, involving significant demolition and reconstruction. They subsequently submitted a claim under the DIY Housebuilders' Scheme, which allows private individuals to recover VAT incurred on the construction of a new dwelling. HMRC rejected the claim on the basis that the project did not amount to the construction of a new building. HMRC considered that sufficient parts of the original bungalow had been retained such that the existing building continued to exist throughout the works.
The Tribunal considered whether extensive works to a bungalow qualified for a DIY Housebuilders’ Scheme refund. Under the façade test in Note 18 to Group 5 of Schedule 8 VATA 1994, a building ceases to be an existing building if it is demolished completely to ground level or, where parts remain above ground, no more than a single façade—or, on a corner site, a double façade—remains and its retention is required by planning consent or similar permission. Because more of the bungalow remained, the works were reconstruction or alteration of an existing building, not construction of a new dwelling, and therefore did not qualify for the DIY Housebuilders Scheme.
Rachel Maddock v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKFTT 1477 (TC)
6.3 Partial exemption and attribution of marketing costs
The FTT held that photography and modelling costs incurred by the taxpayer had a direct and immediate link with both its taxable supplies of goods and its exempt supplies of credit. The costs were therefore residual costs requiring apportionment. The Tribunal upheld HMRC's use of the standard partial exemption method, finding that the taxpayer's proposed alternatives did not produce a more precise result.
During the relevant period, the taxpayer sold goods online and through catalogues and offered customers credit. Sales of goods were taxable, while the provision of credit was exempt.
HMRC considered that photography, modelling and other marketing costs related to both taxable and exempt supplies and should be apportioned using the standard method. The taxpayer argued that the photography and modelling costs related only to displaying goods, and that alternative methods would produce a more accurate result.
The Tribunal found that the photographs were used in promotional materials that encouraged customers to buy particular goods on credit. Credit messages were prominent and, in some cases, superimposed on the photographs. That actual use, not simply the integrated nature of the taxpayer’s business, established a direct and immediate link with both the taxable sales and exempt credit supplies.
The Tribunal held that the standard turnover method provided a fair and reasonable apportionment for the residual marketing costs. The taxpayer had to show that its proposed alternatives provided a more precise apportionment, but the Tribunal was not persuaded on the basis that among other things, they excluded substantial amounts of actual interest income and did not better reflect the use of the costs.
Frasers Group Financial Services Ltd v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKFTT 1496 (TC)
6.4 Supercar driving experience not eligible for reduced rate of VAT
The UT has overturned a FTT decision which held that supercar driving experiences qualified for the temporary reduced rate of VAT for admission to attractions introduced during the covid pandemic. The Tribunal concluded that customers were purchasing an individually selected driving experience rather than the right of admission to an attraction.
The taxpayer operated events at racing venues where customers could either drive or be driven in high-performance vehicles. Customers selected their vehicle and experience, received a safety briefing, and where relevant, were accompanied by an instructor. The taxpayer treated its supplies as qualifying for the temporary reduced rate of VAT applicable to admission to attractions.
The FTT allowed the taxpayer’s appeal, finding the supplies were rights of admission to a facility that was sufficiently similar to a fair or amusement park. It concluded that customers primarily attended the events for enjoyment rather than driving tuition, and that the events had an element of collective participation.
The UT has upheld HMRC’s appeal and overturned the FTT decision. It held that the FTT had misapplied the collective enjoyment test focussing too heavily on the fact that customers were at the same venue and could see each other. The UT found that customers were not paying for admission to a common attraction, each customer had instead purchased a separately selected driving experience, and the event day merely provided the setting for those individual experiences to be delivered. As a result, the supplies should be categorised as driving experiences rather than rights of admission to a qualifying attraction. The reduced rate of VAT did not apply, and HMRC’s assessment was upheld.
Islington Driving Experiences Ltd v HM Revenue & Customs [2026] UKUT 440 (TCC)
7. Tax publications and webinars
7.1 Tax publications
The following Tax publications have been published.
7.2 Webinars
The following client webinars are coming up soon.
3 December @ 12pm - Business post-sale support: Thriving after the transaction
8. And finally
8.1 More marmalade than marmite
John Healey’s first Budget contained no major controversies, but measures are a mixture of bitter and sweet for taxpayers. The consultations show that more major changes might be considered later, perhaps after an election, but for now we will just prepare for more timely payment.
The real win? Lower tariffs on marmalade.
Approval code: NTEH7112660
Glossary
Organisations |
| Courts | Taxes etc |
|
ATT – Association of Tax Technicians | ICAEW - The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales | CA – Court of Appeal | ATED – Annual Tax on Enveloped Dwellings | NIC – National Insurance Contribution |
CIOT – Chartered Institute of Taxation | ICAS - The Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland | CJEU - Court of Justice of the European Union | CGT – Capital Gains Tax | PAYE – Pay As You Earn |
EU – European Union | OECD - Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development | FTT – First-tier Tribunal | CT – Corporation Tax | R&D – Research & Development |
EC – European Commission | OTS – Office of Tax Simplification | HC – High Court | IHT – Inheritance Tax | SDLT – Stamp Duty Land Tax |
HMRC – HM Revenue & Customs | RS – Revenue Scotland | SC – Supreme Court | IT – Income Tax | VAT – Value Added Tax |
HMT – HM Treasury |
| UT – Upper Tribunal |
|
|